Death to EA Sports "NBA Live"
NBA 2K vs. NBA Live: A Hostile Takeover or a Natural Evolution?
By Candace Goodman, Investigative Reporter – The Good Blog
The Basketball Video Game Power Shift No One Saw Coming
There was a time when NBA Live was king. EA Sports dominated the basketball gaming scene, churning out hit after hit. Then, out of nowhere, a challenger appeared—NBA 2K—and within a decade, it did the unthinkable: it killed NBA Live completely.
But was it really just about better gameplay, or was this a hostile takeover from the inside? Did the NBA quietly push 2K to the forefront** while leaving EA in the dust? And could EA’s blunders have been part of a larger strategy to exit the basketball space entirely?
We spoke with industry insiders, former developers, and gaming analysts, and the story we uncovered is bigger than just one franchise losing to another. It’s a story of strategic missteps, licensing battles, financial devastation, and whispered conspiracies that suggest NBA Live never even had a chance.
NBA Live’s Slow, Painful Death
At its peak, NBA Live was untouchable. It had the name recognition, the deep rosters, and the backing of EA Sports, the biggest brand in sports gaming. But somewhere in the mid-2000s, the cracks started to show.
Then came 2010—the year NBA Live was assassinated in broad daylight.
EA decided to completely reboot NBA Live as NBA Elite 11, promising a revolutionary experience. Instead, what they released was a broken, unfinished game. The pre-release demo was a disaster, with the now-infamous “Jesus Bynum” glitch—where Lakers center Andrew Bynum was frozen in a T-pose at midcourt, arms stretched wide like he was waiting for his crucifixion.
Days later, EA did the unthinkable—they canceled the entire game. For the first time in decades, there was no EA basketball game on the shelves.
This was an unprecedented move, one that cost EA an estimated $50–60 million in lost revenue. But more importantly, it handed NBA 2K a free year with zero competition.
By the time NBA Live returned in 2013, it was already too late. The damage was done. Fans had moved on. Every attempt EA made to revive the series—NBA Live 14, 15, 16, 18, and 19—was met with poor sales and weak reviews. By 2019, EA quietly shelved NBA Live indefinitely.
But here’s the question no one is asking: Why would EA, the powerhouse of sports gaming, let one of its flagship franchises die?
Did the NBA Tip the Scales?
The NBA publicly claims that it never favored one game over the other, but the evidence suggests otherwise.
In 2019, the NBA signed a $1.1 billion licensing deal with Take-Two Interactive, the parent company of NBA 2K. Meanwhile, EA received no major renewal announcement, despite having an NBA license for over two decades.
That alone wouldn’t be suspicious—until you realize what happened next.
The NBA fully embraced NBA 2K as its marketing tool of choice. It started pushing player ratings in broadcasts, integrating 2K footage into official NBA promotions, and—most tellingly—launched the NBA 2K League, a fully NBA-backed eSports league.
And where was EA? Completely shut out.
For a company as powerful as EA, how does that happen?
“The NBA wasn’t dumb,” says sports business expert Rod Breslau. “They knew 2K was the future. By the late 2010s, NBA Live was already a corpse. The NBA didn’t kill it, but they sure as hell didn’t try to save it.”
“NBA 2K became bigger than just a game,” adds gaming historian Blake Jorgensen. “Live was just a product. 2K was a culture. The NBA aligned itself with that shift.”
Could it be that the NBA saw NBA Live as a liability—a relic of the past—while 2K was its gateway to a younger, more engaged audience?
The NBA never needed to sign an exclusivity deal like the NFL did with Madden—it simply let EA self-destruct, then backed the winning team.
And if EA knew the NBA was leaning toward 2K, could they have deliberately tanked NBA Live to cut their losses?
The Financial Fallout: Did EA Plan Its Own Exit?
One of the biggest unanswered questions is why EA didn’t fight harder to keep NBA Live alive.
Make no mistake—NBA Live’s collapse was expensive.
- The cancellation of NBA Elite 11 alone cost EA an estimated $50–60 million in lost sales.
- Between 2010 and 2019, industry analysts estimate EA lost over $100 million due to failed NBA Live releases.
- Meanwhile, NBA 2K became a billion-dollar franchise, making more in microtransactions alone than NBA Live did in total sales.
By 2019, NBA Live 19 barely made a dent in the market. EA could have kept throwing money at the problem, but they didn’t.
“It’s like watching a championship team forfeit in the playoffs,” said gaming economist Dr. Joost van Dreunen. “EA could have kept pushing, but they saw the writing on the wall. It was more profitable to walk away.”
Could it be that EA saw an opportunity to quietly exit the basketball space, knowing they could redirect resources to FIFA, Madden, and mobile gaming?
Some former EA insiders believe this was exactly what happened.
“We knew the brand was damaged,” said a former EA Canada developer. “By the mid-2010s, keeping Live alive was like throwing money into a fire.”
In the end, EA may not have lost the war—they may have just decided it wasn’t worth fighting.
Expert Analysis: Why NBA 2K Won
We spoke with former developers from EA and 2K, as well as gaming analysts, and the conclusion was clear:
Scott O’Gallagher (former EA developer):“We tried to reinvent the wheel with Elite 11, and it backfired. We should have just built on what we had.”
Rob Jones (2K developer):“2K focused on realism, Live focused on gimmicks. The fans knew which one felt more like real basketball.”
Peter Moore (former EA Sports President):“We made mistakes, and 2K capitalized. In sports, when you fall behind, it’s hard to catch up.”
NBA 2K didn’t just win because it was better—it won because NBA Live left the door open.
The Game Was Won Before It Started
Was NBA 2K’s dominance inevitable? Maybe.
Did EA make critical mistakes? Absolutely.
Did the NBA quietly nudge 2K into the spotlight? That depends on who you ask.
What’s clear is that NBA 2K took full advantage of every opportunity, while EA made every mistake in the book. Whether EA self-sabotaged NBA Live or was simply outmatched, the result was the same:
NBA Live is dead.
NBA 2K is king.
And unless a new challenger steps up, that won’t change anytime soon.
For basketball gamers, it’s a bittersweet victory. NBA 2K may have won the war, but without competition, who will keep them in check?
For now, the scoreboard reads NBA 2K: 1, NBA Live: 0—and unless EA finds a miracle, that score may never change.
.